It’s hard to believe that two decades have passed since Carrie Underwood first auditioned for American Idol and went on to win the competition. Now, the country music superstar is returning to the show—but this time, she’ll be sitting at the judges’ table as she steps in for Katy Perry. With the premiere of Season 23 set for March 9, 2025, fans couldn’t help but notice Underwood’s stunning transformation in her recent “then” and “now” post. She’s positively glowing, and her confidence is undeniable!
While it’s bittersweet to see Katy Perry depart after six successful seasons, Carrie Underwood is the perfect choice to take her place. As the new judge, she’s stepping into a role that’s especially meaningful given her own journey on the show. The Grammy-winning artist shared a nostalgic Instagram post showcasing her evolution from a small-town girl chasing a dream to a global music icon. In the post, she’s wearing her signature audition color—pink—and sporting those timeless wavy locks. At 41, Underwood radiates joy and poise, ready to embrace this full-circle moment.
Seeing Carrie’s “now” photo alongside her “then” snapshot is a heartwarming reminder of how far she’s come. It feels like just yesterday she was a 21-year-old college student at Northeastern State University, balancing classes and flag football before stepping onto the American Idol stage. Her powerful rendition of Bonnie Raitt’s “I Can’t Make You Love Me” left judges Simon, Paula, and Randy speechless, marking the birth of a superstar. She went on to win Season 4 with unforgettable performances of “Inside Your Heaven,” “Independence Day,” and “Angels Brought Me Here.”
It’s truly fitting that Carrie Underwood is joining American Idol for Season 23. Having once been in the contestants’ shoes, she knows firsthand the pressure of performing under those bright lights. Her unique perspective will allow her to empathize with nervous hopefuls and recognize raw talent when she sees it.
According to showrunner Megan Wolflick, choosing Underwood as Katy Perry’s replacement was a way to honor the 20th anniversary of her life-changing audition. It also marks the first time an Idol alum joins the judges’ panel, bringing a fresh dynamic to the show. With her philosophy of balancing honest feedback with encouragement, Underwood is sure to shine in her new role.
Carrie Underwood’s journey from a young aspiring singer to a platinum-selling artist and now a judge on the very show that launched her career is nothing short of inspiring. Her glow-up isn’t just about her appearance—it reflects her growth as an artist and a person.
Be sure to catch Carrie Underwood’s debut as an American Idol judge on ABC on March 9, with episodes available on Hulu the following day. It’s bound to be an unforgettable season!
