Daniel Emmet, a versatile classical-crossover vocalist, entered his audition on America’s Got Talent confident he would leave a lasting impression on the judges. However, the June 19th episode revealed an unexpected twist when Simon Cowell, known for his blunt critiques, decided to upend Emmet’s plans.

The 25-year-old had prepared an original composition, a creative blend of pop influences, hoping to showcase his unique style. But after only a few moments into his performance, Cowell abruptly stopped him, calling the melody “interesting” but unsatisfactory. (You can watch Daniel Emmet’s AGT audition video below.)

Simon candidly told the aspiring singer that his initial attempt fell flat but offered him a rare second chance—on one condition: he needed to perform a different piece entirely.

When Emmet admitted he didn’t have a backup song prepared, Cowell was visibly unimpressed. Without missing a beat, the judge sent him offstage with a daunting challenge: to return in just one hour and deliver the Il Divo classic “Passerà.”

Despite being visibly nervous and unprepared, Emmet accepted the challenge and came back determined to prove himself. His second performance, a powerful rendition of the Italian aria, stunned both the judges and the audience.

The transformation was nothing short of extraordinary. Although both songs were in Italian, his second performance demonstrated a depth and command that captivated everyone in the room. “It was like night and day,” exclaimed Heidi Klum. “You have ambition, and you did incredibly well,” praised Cowell. Mel B was equally impressed, declaring, “Your passion and delivery were completely unexpected—perfect!”

By the end of his performance, the entire judging panel was on their feet, joined by an ecstatic audience roaring with applause. Emmet’s journey on AGT had officially begun, marked by an unforgettable comeback that showcased his talent and resilience.